Kidlit Bloggers

This is one of the blogs that my students and I created for a course on young adult literature. For this particular blog, students weren't required to post and we used the space as a complement to our twice a week sessions. The "Issues of Diversity in Children's and Adolescent Literature" blog shows what it looked like when I had a blog as an instructor and asked students to create and link their own review blogs to the course site.
.
Showing posts with label Critical Theory Today. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Critical Theory Today. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Critical Theory Today Reactions

Good thing I caught this before class- my post from last night did not upload correctly. Here's hoping this one is successful:

Because I am not an English major, I take the backseat most of the time when it comes to reading. I thoroughly enjoy books but I do not stress their deeper meanings beyond the text most of the time, unless challenged by peers or a class. When I saw the book requirement for Critical Theory Today, I was pretty nervous. Seeing theory and connecting it with literature seemed daunting- however I was very surprised to read the first chapter with ease. Tyson spoke of an instance where a student didn't know what "the death of the author" meant during a conversation and its affect on his comprehension of the discussion. This is typical of my own self so I was drawn in to continue discovering how theories can help make a more fruitful experience when reading a book. Of course, no one has to read every book and analyze it through theory- but it will be interesting to start looking at certain texts with a different perspective, especially if the themes make any certain theory come to mind. I anticipate going back to some of my old favorites and looking for different connections I can make to larger meanings/themes.

One quote that particularly caught my attention was "Knowledge is what constitutes our relationship to ourselves and to our world, for it is the lens through which we view ourselves and our world. Change the lens and you change both the view and the viewer." It helps motivate you to keep reading the text as well as challenge yourself.

Finally- a list of my top five YAL:
1- The Wind Up Bird Chronicle
2- The Perks of Being a Wallflower
3- Kafka on the Shore
4- Things Fall Apart
5- The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay

Monday, February 1, 2010

Critical Theory Today

I was impressed with the first chapter of Critical Theory Today. I am definitely one of those people who reads for enjoyment, especially during the school year when I am busy with the piles of homework assigned. I have loved reading since I was a child and have never really stopped. I can, and have on multiple occasions, sit in one place for hours and hours with a good book in my hand. And of course, I feel the heartbreak when a story ends and I am no longer immersed in that world. Analyzing books has never appealed to me, because I have always felt that I will lose something if I look to critically. I believe that some books weren't written with a deeper purpose and were simply meant to be enjoyed.

But after the first chapter of Critical Theory Today I am ready to give theory and reading a chance. I don't believe I will be fully converted, but I appreciated the simple way the author reached out to readers like me. The author made a point of pointing out the prejudices people have against analyzing texts and then explained why we would be okay using theory despite them. After reading this chapter I am much more willing to give critical theory a chance and maybe even enjoy it.

Also, I am really looking forward to American Born Chinese after all of the previous posts. I think I will pick it up right now!

Moore/Critical Theory

So I posted earlier about American Born Chinese because I read that before the articles, but before moving on to the articles, I just wanted to say I agreed with the other post about it and am also curious about class discussion next week. It takes a while to get into, and has some blatant discrimination, but contains lots of other cultural references and an overall good message. Also, it's easy to read in one sitting in the comic book format.

Anyways, I really liked the Theory as Prism article. It really captured the essence of examining texts in different ways and provided good detailed examples. All the subtitle areas were really intriguing and I loved all of the tie-ins with biblical references, cultural references, and gender references. Also, it really made me want to read "Jacob Have I Loved." Has anyone actually read this book who could give me some advice?

In relation to critical theory, reading the first chapter has made me a little less hesistant about it. I was nervous about whether I'd like it or be good at it, but after reading how and why it is important, along with the Prism article, it sounds like class should really teach me how to find better books and better understand them.

Sorry this is just a bunch of jumbled thoughts and feelings about the readings. But if anyone really does know about the "Jacob Have I Loved "book, please let me know. I'm always looking for good reads.

I actually liked American Born Chinese

Fist, I would like to respond briefly to the comments some people made about American Born Chinese. I actually found this graphic novel to be engrossing, in that I set out to read just a few pages and ended up reading the entire thing in one sitting. I actually enjoyed the way the three portions of the text intertwined at the finish, especially with the common theme of the identity crisis/denial between the characters. I thought all of that was quite clever. I'm curious to see how we approach this text tomorrow. I am not very experienced with graphic novels, so this was a new experience for me. I thought it made some risky choices of displaying stereotypes while juxtaposing them with a character who is consciously setting themselves in stark contrast with those presumed traits. So did anyone really like it?

On another note, I would like to encourage anyone who has a little extra time or an overachieving streak to read about Deconstructive Theory. If you enjoy playing with the certainties/uncertainties of language, tearing things apart, or if you have problems with absolutist interpretations of texts as mandated by the teacher, you can really have a lot of fun with this theory. I actually utilized it as part of a project for another class assignment! Check it out if you have the time; otherwise I'll be telling you all about it with my group members sometime in April!

Critical Theory Today

After receiving the book list for this class I was somewhat terrified. Not because of the number of books but the title of one, Critical Theory Today. My first formal introduction to literary analysis was disastrous. My junior year in high school the english department introduced a new class, AP Language. I enrolled in the class but wasn't quite sure what to expect. My first assignment was to annotate an article. After turning in 3 re-writes of my original work and several meetings with my teacher I still hadn't gotten anything out of the class. I dropped the class and moved into a lower level after I got the worst grade I had ever gotten on a paper. I quickly came to the conclusion that the class was useless and my teacher was taking the text to mean WAY more than it actually did. I was convinced that she was making connections that weren't really there. Once I read chapter 1 of Critical Theory Today I felt much more at ease. A quote from page 1 described my situation perfectly. "With notable exceptions, most theoretical writing...is filled with technical terms and theoretical concepts that assume a level of familiarity newcomers simply don't have." Even after meeting with my teacher several times she was never able to convey to me exactly what I wasn't doing right. All she was ever able to tell me was "You need to do more". My answer, "More of what?!" It is a comfort to know that I am not the only one out there that didn't quite grasp the subject. Tyson writes, "...in order to understand some things clearly we must restrict our focus in a way that highlights certain elements and ignores others..." (p.3). I now look forward to looking at literature in different ways and focusing on different aspects of it.

Sunday, January 31, 2010

Why Critical Theory Today Matters (IMHO)

The mere mention of “literary theory” struck me instantly as something with which I’d be unfamiliar. I’m not an English major, and a textbook with as conventional a title as Critical Theory Today seems so fundamentally “college-level English” – so esoteric, really – that I didn't think I'd care, that I believed I had no reason to be familiar with any of the concepts it addressed. Reading the introductory chapter, I realize now this was just a defense mechanism: in the event that I didn’t understand the majority of what I was reading, I could brush it off as being just the sort of rhetoric that had pushed me away from the study of English in the first place. (Tyson, after all, mentions “fear of failure” at the outset of the book as one of the two main reasons why theory is avoided [1].) As it turns out, however, the book (or at least Ch. 1) was downright comforting, written to gently highlight the advantages of using a informed, theoretical approach to reading -- approaches that the author appears to use and appreciate on her own time as well as in the classroom. I felt genuinely heartened by her appeals to learn theory, since, as she mentions, even our unsystematic, “raw” interpretations of text are informed by some sort of theory, whether we are aware of it or not (4). Thus it is empowering to understand and organize our opinions as they fall into certain ideologies. Further, armed with more “lenses” by which we can interpret texts, ourselves, and the world, we can articulate multi-faceted, fully realized, credible, and interesting literary opinions (not to mention great cocktail-party banter!) (10). This introductory piece perfectly “logic-ed” me out of the fears I had, making me genuinely wonder how much I’ve been missing all these years, reading occasional books for pleasure without any real means by which to analyze them.

It is worth noting, before I continue to heap compliments on Tyson, that the examples she used to exemplify the alienation felt by students left “out of the loop” by theorists struck a particular chord with me (1-2).

(This being a blog, I’m tempted to give boring personal backstory, so please bear with me.)

My 20th birthday resolution – inane, I realize, but the root of my renewed interest in English – was to become “culturally informed, “ to make up for all the ignorant teen years I spent holed up in my room, tuning out “boring” subjects like literature, art, and politics, and consequently losing touch with the world around me. (Moreso, this stemmed out of a sudden realization that I’m an adult now, and I no longer have my parents to ask whenever I’m curious about an unfamiliar reference. If I’m going to have valid opinions and truly feel intelligent, it’s up to me to do the research.) Thus I took it upon myself to start reading in earnest over Winter Break, and found myself with both classics and contemporary favorites, notably David Foster Wallace (very non-YAL, I am aware). I also began to soak up as many blogs and news websites as I could, including Slate, on which I found the attached article by Nathan Heller. Both a book review by DFW in his collection of essays, Consider the Lobster, on a biography of Fyodor Dostoyevsky, and the Heller article, a review/analysis of a Zadie Smith book I’d been skimming, coincidentally found their way into my hands around the same time. While of totally different sources, both essays are firmly rooted in theoretical discussion – a discussion about which I was thoroughly uninformed as I began to read them.

The essay “Joseph Frank’s Dostoyevsky” (which I'm not expecting any of you to have read, but I’ll attempt to explain anyway) is presented in the context of a book that addresses all sorts of subjects: a lobster festival, September 11th, talk radio, and even the John McCain 2000 campaign. In no way was the book meant to be confined to the eyes of literary theorists, but that did not stop the author from including references to the “New Criticism” and the “intentional fallacy” – a concept that, needless to say, required a trip to Wikipedia. (I suppose having CTT would have simplified things a bit.) What I came to discover was that the “intentional fallacy” arises out of the same “death of the author” concept of which Tyson made special note (1-2). And with or without Wikipedia, I still felt quite alienated by this strange, pretentious language. I mulled over the article, which, I deduced, examined the concept as it pertains to biographers (if the author has no bearing on reader perception, is it ever worthwhile to study an author’s life as a manner of understanding their work?), but I couldn’t help but wonder, once I had finished, whether I’d actually understood any of what I just read.

Likewise, Heller’s article discusses how fiction should be read according to one author, Zadie Smith, whose newest collection of essays, Changing My Mind, showcases the many identities she’s taken on while pursuing different styles of writing. (This actually solidifies Tyson’s concept of one reader using multiple theories like multiple lenses, to shape many, often complementary literary critiques.) More importantly, the Slate article mentions the “death of the author” debate specifically, with reference to Roland Barthes, who first articulated this sentiment, versus Vladimir Nabokov, who believed that the author was in total control of the readers’ perceptions. Luckily, these particular concepts were somewhat clarified, but the article’s central premise – the idea of theorists contemplating, in depth, the nature of fiction – was utterly foreign to me. (Even more foreign to me was that regular Slate readers were seeing the same words as I was, but actually understanding them.) I obviously learned something (to the effect that I was able to backtrack, re-locate the article, and connect it to our class), but I had no idea of this at the time.

Long story short, I was elated to come across yet another mention of “death of the author” in Tyson, regardless of the fact that it’s a small, isolated element of literary theory, since its explanation in CTT was worded with the understanding of how scary these thoughts could seem to a new student. Her arguments for theory, and for reading her book to understand it, rang so true that the text came full circle. Moreover, realizing that a seemingly obscure notion of theory could find its way into so many popular sources emphasized how imperative it is, to me at least, that I use this book and this class to start “getting the references” within today’s literary (and greater cultural) dialogue.

I’m probably far over the required wordcount, but this post would be completely irrelevant without an attempt to justify how YAL fits into this mix. It appears that what we attempt to do in this class is further legitimize this genre of literature by applying the theories presented in Critical Theory Today, and further that doing so is only a natural extension of what I’ve observed in the essays mentioned above. If theory is indeed becoming mainstream, the most we could do to prove the literary merits of a particular style is to continue this trend, drawing theoretical analyses from the books that both adults and young adults are actually reading. This brings both into the spotlight, highlighting the most enlightening aspects of theory alongside the insightful, innovative nature of today’s best YAL.

Saturday, January 30, 2010

Critical Theory Today

I just finished reading chapter one in critical theory today and the quote on page one that Valerie quoted rings true for me. I am supposed to be a teacher in two and a half short years. If I can't understand theories how am I supposed to teach them to my students? If I fail I will be failing more than just my knowledge, I will be failing my future students as well. The second part is that I love to read literature. I have loved reading ever since I was a child and my mom used to read to me. It is probably the main reason I am going to be a English teacher is so I can share that love with others. I feel like if I have to analyze everything I read I will love it less and look at it more like a job instead of fun. Then again when I learned to critically analyze the media, watching TV did not become less fun so I am sure it is the same with this. This is just all new to me because I was not taught theories in high school, I get to learn them for the first time now.

Friday, January 29, 2010

Week 4: Thinking about Theory; Graphic Novels

For Tuesday:
  • Read "Theory as Prism" (Moore) and chapter 1 of Critical Theory Today. What has been your experience using critical theory? Did Tyson's experience ring true? Were you persuaded by her arguments that theory can enhance reading?
  • This is not required, but you might also want to skim the theory chapter you will be reading for your group presentation.
  • No critical reflection paper due. Instead, write a post or comment on the blog. Your contribution can be about anything: a key idea in the class, a response to a quote from the reading, a book suggestion, a link to an interesting on-line resource. Our main goal is to make this a discussion among everyone in the class. :-)
For Thursday:
  • Read "Reading Lessons 101" (Rudiger). How does reading graphic novels differ from reading other types of YAL? What place do graphic novels have in YAL?
  • Read and come prepared to discuss American Born Chinese. How does this text "work" as a graphic novel? How is it YAL? What questions or points in the text do you want to discuss? (You might think about trying out an idea with your group as the basis for the Critical Reflection paper due on 2/9). 

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Response to Tuesday Readings

I was doing the reading for Tuesday, and there were a couple things in Critical Theory Today that stuck out to me. Critical theory is something that I was only really introduced to in the last few years, and my first interactions with it were really convoluted and frustrating (thank you, AP Lang). I don't know if anyone else took that AP English class in high school? If not, the basic point of it was to learn how to deconstruct the ideas and arguments of authors and figure out how they made their writing effective; it had a lot to do with analysis, and in general seemed rather pointless to me: why did I need to know how they made it effective, if I knew why it was effective? A quote in Tyson made me think of this:

"...reveal the two-fold nature of our reluctance to study theory: (1) fear of failure and (2) fear of losing the intimate, magical connection with literature that is our reason for reading it in the first place." (pg 1)

I can remember having this exact feeling when I was first asked to analyze - not discuss - literature. The longer I was in the class, though, the more I began to realize the importance of being able to take apart an author's writing. When we understand the how of what makes something effective, we really gain a better understanding of the why as well. We can get a clearer picture of all the factors that combine to give the words on the page the meaning we glean from them, and we can articulate that meaning more fully, as opposed to a general 'I really like this book!' It reminds me a lot of music: you can appreciate music with out understanding the finer details of how its constructed, but often the deeper an understanding you have of the mechanics, the easier it is to interpret a composers meaning and intentions. So it is with literature.