I thought the connection Yang made to William Hung in American Born Chinese was interesting. I have been asked to post this and hope that for those that did not see the connection will see it! The panel when Chin-Kee is singing She Bang on the Library table seems to come from an actual person named William Hung. He was a contestant for American Idol in 2004. He is Chinese and not a very good singer, but he seemed to capture the attention of the American public and became super popular. I have put up a link for you to see the youtube video of his audition so you can see how it connects to the graphic novel.
William Hung Audition
Showing posts with label American Born Chinese. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Born Chinese. Show all posts
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Thursday, February 11, 2010
Critiquing vs using stereotypes/offensive language
This morning I read an article that used some graphic language for the purposes of critiquing the use of that very same language. It made me think about our discussion of American Born Chinese and the web of questions that was raised about whether the stereotypical representation of Chin-Kee was "necessary" in the text; whether it was necessary, but taken too far; how the representations "worked" as characterization and/or as an element in the plot and resolution; how different readers might interpret and appropriate those stereotypes; how the text did or did not invite the reader to take the character seriously; etc.
If anyone wants to keep talking about this, feel free to comment!
If anyone wants to keep talking about this, feel free to comment!
Thursday, February 4, 2010
Week 4: American Born Chinese, Intertextuality, and Marxist Theory
On Tuesday we'll continue our discussion of American Born Chinese. We'll have time for you to share what you discover as you write your critical reflection papers, but we'll also use the text as an opportunity to talk about "intertextuality".
Here's a recommendation for your paper:
On Thursday the Marxist Theory group will introduce us to the theory and provide us with some practice generating questions and/or using Marxist theory to help us reading texts. If you like, you might want to look at the chapter on Marxism in the Tyson text.
Here's a recommendation for your paper:
- Introduce: Begin with a question or aspect of American Born Chinese that interests you. Provide the reader with a little context related to that idea.
- Insert: Describe the panel or series of panels you intend to analyze to the reader. Focus on the elements most related to the idea you plan to develop.
- Interpret: "Read" the text for us--tell us what we can discover by reading the text in this way!
On Thursday the Marxist Theory group will introduce us to the theory and provide us with some practice generating questions and/or using Marxist theory to help us reading texts. If you like, you might want to look at the chapter on Marxism in the Tyson text.
Tuesday, February 2, 2010
American Born Chinese
I finished American Born Chinese last night. I liked that the book was a quick read, probably because it was a comic. As I was reading it, I could not help but think of the boys I babysit over the summer. The oldest one, who is 13, would have absolutely loved this book, and I think it is because of some of stereo-types and references to inappropriate/gross things- i.e. peeing in the coke. Therefore, I think that this book really appeals to the 12-15 age group for boys.
However, while I think many YA, male readers would like this book, I think that it did enforce some strong stereo-types that our culture currently has about Asian people. Some examples of this include: pp 114- Chin-Kee eating cat, pp 203- Chin-Kee singing "She Bangs", this reminded my of the guy on the first season of American Idol who sang this song (he was Chinese)- I am not sure if this was meant to represent this or just a coincidence. I think that while these books are funny, they can also be harmful because they continue to enforce common ideas and stereo-types of others.
However, while I think many YA, male readers would like this book, I think that it did enforce some strong stereo-types that our culture currently has about Asian people. Some examples of this include: pp 114- Chin-Kee eating cat, pp 203- Chin-Kee singing "She Bangs", this reminded my of the guy on the first season of American Idol who sang this song (he was Chinese)- I am not sure if this was meant to represent this or just a coincidence. I think that while these books are funny, they can also be harmful because they continue to enforce common ideas and stereo-types of others.
Monday, February 1, 2010
Critical Theory Today
I was impressed with the first chapter of Critical Theory Today. I am definitely one of those people who reads for enjoyment, especially during the school year when I am busy with the piles of homework assigned. I have loved reading since I was a child and have never really stopped. I can, and have on multiple occasions, sit in one place for hours and hours with a good book in my hand. And of course, I feel the heartbreak when a story ends and I am no longer immersed in that world. Analyzing books has never appealed to me, because I have always felt that I will lose something if I look to critically. I believe that some books weren't written with a deeper purpose and were simply meant to be enjoyed.
But after the first chapter of Critical Theory Today I am ready to give theory and reading a chance. I don't believe I will be fully converted, but I appreciated the simple way the author reached out to readers like me. The author made a point of pointing out the prejudices people have against analyzing texts and then explained why we would be okay using theory despite them. After reading this chapter I am much more willing to give critical theory a chance and maybe even enjoy it.
Also, I am really looking forward to American Born Chinese after all of the previous posts. I think I will pick it up right now!
But after the first chapter of Critical Theory Today I am ready to give theory and reading a chance. I don't believe I will be fully converted, but I appreciated the simple way the author reached out to readers like me. The author made a point of pointing out the prejudices people have against analyzing texts and then explained why we would be okay using theory despite them. After reading this chapter I am much more willing to give critical theory a chance and maybe even enjoy it.
Also, I am really looking forward to American Born Chinese after all of the previous posts. I think I will pick it up right now!
Moore/Critical Theory
So I posted earlier about American Born Chinese because I read that before the articles, but before moving on to the articles, I just wanted to say I agreed with the other post about it and am also curious about class discussion next week. It takes a while to get into, and has some blatant discrimination, but contains lots of other cultural references and an overall good message. Also, it's easy to read in one sitting in the comic book format.
Anyways, I really liked the Theory as Prism article. It really captured the essence of examining texts in different ways and provided good detailed examples. All the subtitle areas were really intriguing and I loved all of the tie-ins with biblical references, cultural references, and gender references. Also, it really made me want to read "Jacob Have I Loved." Has anyone actually read this book who could give me some advice?
In relation to critical theory, reading the first chapter has made me a little less hesistant about it. I was nervous about whether I'd like it or be good at it, but after reading how and why it is important, along with the Prism article, it sounds like class should really teach me how to find better books and better understand them.
Sorry this is just a bunch of jumbled thoughts and feelings about the readings. But if anyone really does know about the "Jacob Have I Loved "book, please let me know. I'm always looking for good reads.
Anyways, I really liked the Theory as Prism article. It really captured the essence of examining texts in different ways and provided good detailed examples. All the subtitle areas were really intriguing and I loved all of the tie-ins with biblical references, cultural references, and gender references. Also, it really made me want to read "Jacob Have I Loved." Has anyone actually read this book who could give me some advice?
In relation to critical theory, reading the first chapter has made me a little less hesistant about it. I was nervous about whether I'd like it or be good at it, but after reading how and why it is important, along with the Prism article, it sounds like class should really teach me how to find better books and better understand them.
Sorry this is just a bunch of jumbled thoughts and feelings about the readings. But if anyone really does know about the "Jacob Have I Loved "book, please let me know. I'm always looking for good reads.
I actually liked American Born Chinese
Fist, I would like to respond briefly to the comments some people made about American Born Chinese. I actually found this graphic novel to be engrossing, in that I set out to read just a few pages and ended up reading the entire thing in one sitting. I actually enjoyed the way the three portions of the text intertwined at the finish, especially with the common theme of the identity crisis/denial between the characters. I thought all of that was quite clever. I'm curious to see how we approach this text tomorrow. I am not very experienced with graphic novels, so this was a new experience for me. I thought it made some risky choices of displaying stereotypes while juxtaposing them with a character who is consciously setting themselves in stark contrast with those presumed traits. So did anyone really like it?
On another note, I would like to encourage anyone who has a little extra time or an overachieving streak to read about Deconstructive Theory. If you enjoy playing with the certainties/uncertainties of language, tearing things apart, or if you have problems with absolutist interpretations of texts as mandated by the teacher, you can really have a lot of fun with this theory. I actually utilized it as part of a project for another class assignment! Check it out if you have the time; otherwise I'll be telling you all about it with my group members sometime in April!
Yang A.B.C.
So I know this is a little bit ahead of schedule, but I had time to sit down and read Yang's "American Born Chinese" this weekend. At first, I was not into it at all and wanted to stop reading, but by the end found it was worth the read. So, I just wanted to let everybody know don't give up on it, and it might surprise you. See you tomorrow.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)